The NSPCC is accusing Apple of failing to effectively monitor its platforms and identify images and videos of child sexual abuse, according to child safety experts.
This raises serious concerns about how the company is managing the growing amount of this material, which is also influenced by artificial intelligence.
The National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) in the UK is accusing Apple of seriously underestimating the extent of child sexual abuse material (CSAM) on its products. According to police data available to the NSPCC, in just one year, predators used Apple’s iCloud, iMessage and Facetime to store and distribute CSAM in more cases in England and Wales than the company reported for all other countries combined.
Read also: Apple: Warns millions of iPhone users—Stop using Google Chrome
According to data gathered through Freedom of Information requests and shared exclusively with the Guardian, the children’s charity found that Apple was linked to 337 recorded incidents of child abuse imagery between April 2022 and March 2023 in England and Wales. In 2023, Apple filed just 267 reports of suspected CSAM on its platforms globally with the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC). In contrast, other major tech companies, such as Google, reported more than 1.47 million cases, and Metareported more than 30.6 million, according to the NCMEC’s annual report.
All US-based tech companies are required to report all instances of CSAM they detect on their platforms to NCMEC. The Virginia-based agency acts as a clearinghouse for child abuse reports from around the world, tracking and forwarding them to relevant law enforcement agencies. Apple’s iMessage service is encrypted, meaning it can’t see the content of its users’ messages. However, the same is true for Meta’s WhatsApp, which submitted about 1.4 million reports of suspected CSAM to NCMEC in 2023.
“There is a worrying disparity between the number of child abuse crimes occurring on Apple’s services in the UK and the almost negligible number of global reports of abusive content made to authorities,” said Richard Collard, head of online policy for child safety at the NSPCC. “Apple is significantly lagging behind many of its competitors in tackling child sexual abuse, at a time when all tech companies should be investing in security and preparing for the imminent implementation of the UK’s Safer Internet Act.”.
Apple declined to comment and referred the Guardian to statements from last August, where it said it had decided not to move forward with its iCloud photo scanning program for CSAM, opting instead for an approach that prioritizes the security and privacy of its users.
See also: Apple wasn't saving deleted iOS photos to iCloud
In late 2022, Apple decided to abandon plans to launch an iCloud photo scanning tool. The tool, known as neuralMatch, would scan images before they were uploaded to iCloud storage, comparing them to a database of known child abuse images using fingerprints.
However, there was a backlash from digital rights groups, who were concerned that this could violate the privacy and security of iCloud users . On the other hand, child protection advocates condemned the removal of the feature.
“Apple is not detecting CSAM on a large scale in most of its environments,” said Sarah Gardner, CEO of the Heat Initiative, a Los Angeles-based nonprofit focused on protecting children. “They are providing insufficient information and have not invested in trust and safety teams to manage this situation.”
Apple's announcement in June of its new AI feature, Apple Intelligence, has raised concerns among child safety experts. "Apple's push to develop AI is concerning, as AI-generated child abuse material puts children at risk and impacts law enforcement's ability to protect young victims, particularly because Apple has avoided incorporating technology to protect children," Collard said. Apple says the AI system, developed in partnership with OpenAI , will personalize user experiences, automate tasks, and enhance user privacy
In 2023, NCMEC received over 4,700 reports of CSAM generated through AI, and it expects these reports to increase in the future. Since the AI models that generate CSAM are trained on “real” child abuse images, AI-generated images also contribute to the victimization of children. In June, it was reported that pedophiles are using AI to create new images of their victims.
🔒 Protect your privacy with Proton VPN
Swiss VPN from the creators of Proton Mail — strict no-logs policy, strong encryption, and built-in NetShield that blocks ads, trackers, & malware.
- ✔ No-logs, based in Switzerland (except 14-Eyes)
- ✔ NetShield: blocks ads, trackers & malicious domains
- ✔ Covers all devices — free version available
The link is an affiliate link — SecNews may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. It does not affect the independence of our article writing.
Read more: iCloud gets a major upgrade in iOS 18
“The company is operating in an area that we know can be extremely dangerous for children and it doesn’t have the track record to handle it,” Gardner said. “Apple is a black hole.”.
Source: theguardian
